Hi guys. I hope this is the correct forum for this question, and I hope you don't mind me butting in here without so much as a by-your-leave (I'll post an intro thread soon!)
I also posted this question in a non-Tolkien forum of my acquaintance. My apologies if this is an unacceptable cross-post. While there are some lore-masters of high worth over there, it's always questionable whether a thread concerning LotR will gain footing or sink like a stone. At the moment, it seems to be doing the latter.
With that, here is the meat of my question. It may be essentially unanswerable, in which case I look forward to rampant speculation!
So when the Elder Children of Ilúvatar awoke in Cuiviénen, we are told that Oromë, on one of his hunts, was the first of the Valar to discover them. We are then told, of course, that Melkor was really the first to discover them, and set forth immediately to corrupt, frighten, and enslave them, leading to some being captured and tortured, and eventually turned into Orcs.
So, given that Cuiviénen was located on the shores of the Sea of Helcar, and that "many waters flowed thither from heights in the east", and even that the first sound that the Elves heard when they awoke was the sound of water flowing over stone, why wasn't Ulmo the first of the Valar to be aware of them?
After all, it was said that wherever water flowed, Ulmo had awareness - from the oceans to the rivers, to small springs, and even in the deep waters flowing under the realm of Melkor.
So what gives? Did Eru hide their existence from him (and for that matter, the delving of Utumno, of which the Valar were not aware), so that Oromë could be the first to find them? Why? Or did he drop the ball? OR, was he, in fact, the first to find the Elves after all, and simply said nothing, because he always was in favor of the Elves being free, never coming to Valinor?
PS: While we're on the subject of Arda's theology, I wonder if the Elves who were corrupted and became Orcs are still essentially immortal, being reborn into their children...
Actually Samnite, Uinen and Ossë were in charge of the "Inner Seas" , not Ulmo, he delighted in the Deep seas, so he could not have been aware of that phenomenon with Cuiviénen
__________________
Hey dol! merry dol! ring a dong dillo! Ring a dong! hop along! fal lal the willow! Tom Bom, Jolly Tom, Tom Bombadillo!
I appreciate the reply, but I must respectfully disagree. So sayeth the Master ( Valaquenta, Quenta Silmarillion):
"For all seas, lakes, rivers, fountains, and springs are in his government; so that the Elves say that spirit of Ulmo runs in all the veins of the world. Thus news comes to Ulmo, even in the deeps, of all the needs and griefs of Arda, which otherwise would be hidden from Manwë."
I would say that upon their waking, the Elves were in deep need of guidance from the Valar, and were under considerable grief because of Melkor's shenanigans.
This is a matter for Galin (our scholar around here) to take on.
I had never thought of making the connections that you point out - that Ulmo should have discovered the Elves first, although I was aware of the passage you quoted from the Silmarillion.
Now that you mention it, I don't recall reading anything by Tolkien to explain this problem. Therefore it may be what you said, that Ulmo wanted the Elves to remain ignorant of the Valar (and viceversa), although it is highly improbable that he would have thought this possible, seeing how the Elves would multiply and migrate in any case, and sooner or later they would be discovered. Put Mekor and his constant threat in, and it would be weird that Ulmo would not want the other Valar to know of the Elves at all (and this is not conflicting with his reluctance to have Elves removed to Valinor).
May it be that Tolkien did not notice the issue himself? After all, Orome is a likely candidate to find them because he was said to travel often in Middle-earth, while Ulmo was said to stay in the Outer Seas (and so Tolkien might have considered - just for once in the stories - these characters not as mighty gods, but as persons seeing with their own eyes and hearing with their own ears, in which case Ulmo could not have hoped to discover the Elves.) Just a thought...
This is indeed something to look into. However I don't think the text means it in the way we are interpreting it. I don't think it is meant to imply that Ulmo knew of all the goings on in the world simply because he had a presence in the water. Certainly if Ulmo had willfully gone to the eastern shores of Cuivienen he would have found the elves but as he prefered the deeps then he simply may not have gone there.
Another possibility is that it was fate that had ordained how the elves would be found. In the same way that Beren was able to pass the Girdle of Melian - fate guided him - perhaps something similar can answer this.
I think that Ulmo was present but it was the will of Illuvatar that Ulmo obeyed. Meaning, Ulmo was respectful of Illuvatar and merely watched and provided for the First Born in the infancy of their 'coming to be' i.e: Water. Water has always played throughout mythologies as either; calm, soothing, healing, or destructive, powerful and merciless (with good reason). Maybe Tolkein wanted to lay down an earth-real carpet (so to speak) for His first born. As the man upstairs laid down the Garden of Eden for Adam & Eve. Someplace they can sustain their selves.
If Ulmo was truly able to know the goings on simply by the presence of water than surely he would be nigh all-knowing of the events of Arda? This would surely be a source of annoyance for Mandos as an intrusion upon his area of expertise?
Also, it says that Melkor was the first one to be aware of the awakening of the Quendi, not Oromë. and sends shadows and evil spirits to spy. So basically it was not Oromë, but Melkor.
__________________
Hey dol! merry dol! ring a dong dillo! Ring a dong! hop along! fal lal the willow! Tom Bom, Jolly Tom, Tom Bombadillo!
"Ossë is a vassal of Ulmo and he is a master of the seas that wash the shores of Middle-Earth. He does not go in the deeps, but loves the coasts and the isles..." (Valaquenta)
So if Ulmo hangs out in the depths of the Ocean, he may have messengers send word to him of things going on around the world. These messengers could be any kind of sea creatures sent to him by Ossë or Uinen.
Doesn't Manwë have heralds and messengers in the form of Eagles to relay information for him? If so, then Ulmo could go about things in a similar way. Rather than simply hearing all things directly from the water, he has word sent to him through water, like Manwë has word sent to him through the air.
He would still be able to find things out, just not instantaneously. This would give both Melkor and Oromë the time to find the Quendi before Ulmo.
__________________
"The man who does not read good books has no advantage over the man who can't read them." Mark Twain
Maybe we're looking at this at the wrong angle. How many of us have made mistakes? At work or home or wherever? Everyone right? Is it inconcievible to think that JRR Tolkien may have simply not thought to have Ulmo first discover them? Not to say that the great Tolkien made a mistake, just that he went with Orome. Even if it doesn't make sense to us.
__________________
But no wizardry nor spell, neither fang nor venom,nor devil's art nor beast-strength, could overthrow Huan of Valinor;
It could have been a minor oversight. The question is whether there is something in the lore that accounts for it, either intentionally by Tolkien or by chance.
__________________
Utúlie'n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatári, utúlie'n aurë! Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva!
Do you mean why didn't Mandos know of the awakening of the elves first, nat?
__________________
Utúlie'n aurë! Aiya Eldalië ar Atanatári, utúlie'n aurë! Auta i lómë! Aurë entuluva!
Page 1 of 1 sorted by
Chatbox
Please log in to join the chat!
Previous poll results (What is the 'Mightiest' weapon in Tolkiens myth?): Gurthang, blade of Turin - 28%, Narsil, sword of Elendil - 12%, Anduril, Sword of King Ellesar Aragorn - 23%, The Mace of the Witch King - 5%, Grond the dread hammer/hammer of the underworld -19%, Black axe of Gothmog - 4, Glamdring of Gandalf - 7%, Orcrist of Thorin - 1%
A NEW POLL HAS BEEN ADDED TO TOLKIEN FORUMS
Tolkien Forums - The Mythical world of J.R.R Tolkien
